The personite problem
Webb1 apr. 2024 · I show that the personite problem can be reworked as an argument against stage theorists. The stage theorist can respond by rejecting an assumption of the … Webbpersonites. A person could have been exactly like that personite. Perhaps your life could have been cut short, something just like the personite you consider could have sprung …
The personite problem
Did you know?
WebbPersonites are shorter-lived, person-like things that extend across part of a person’s life. Their existence follows from the standard perdurance view of persons. Johnston argues … Webb10 okt. 2016 · Shareable Link. Use the link below to share a full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Learn more.
Webbdetails. Mark Johnston and Eric Olson have both pressed what Johnston has dubbed the personite problem. Personites, if they exist, are person-like entities whose lives extend over a continuous proper part of a person’s life. They are so person-like that they seem to have moral status if persons do. Webb2 The personite problem Johnston and Olson are both concerned with the problem posed for ethical thinking by what Johnston calls personites (and Olson calls subpeople): ‘‘shorter-lived very person-like things that extend …
WebbMark Johnston has recently argued that four-dimensionalist theories of persistence are incompatible with some of our most basic ethical and prudential principles. I argue that although Johnston’s arguments succeed on a worm-theoretic account of persistence, they fail on a stage-theoretic account. So much the worse, I conclude, for the worm ... Webb11 juli 2024 · Though a personite thinks or utters the word ‘I’, the referent isn’t that very personite; instead, ‘I’ refers to the person. Thus both the person and the personites know that “I am a person” and that “I have the persistence conditions of a person”—since the referent of ‘I’ (the person) is indeed a person and has the corresponding persistence …
Webb3 nov. 2024 · This response focuses on Peacocke’s subtle treatment of the identity of subjects and his intriguing account of how it might resolve the personite or fellow-traveller worries set out in my “Personites, Maximality and Ontological Trash” (Nous, 2024), “The Personite Problem” (Philosophical Perspectives, 2016) and, with Sarah-Jane Leslie, … images of paisley designWebbFor every person, there are countless personites. It seems that if persons matter, then so do personites. But this raises serious challenges to ordinary mora... list of background checkerWebbCall this the absurd result. Mark’s argument that four-dimensionalism leads to the absurd result goes as follows. On four-dimensionalism, there is a “personite” who is a temporal part of Mark and who exists just during the agonizing month of May in which he learns Hungarian. Call this personite Shorty. list of backing groupsWebb24 mars 2024 · In the not-too-distant future, a team of scientists discovers a new technology that allows for the creation of advanced artificial beings known as Personites. As they delve deeper into their research, they uncover unexpected complexities and ethical dilemmas that threaten the very existence of the Personites. When a rebellion of … list of backgrounds in d\u0026dWebbFor every person, there are countless personites. It seems that if persons matter, then so do personites. But this raises serious challenges to ordinary mora... images of palak paneerWebb2024 (English) In: Philosophical Review, ISSN 0031-8108, E-ISSN 1558-1470, Vol. 130, no 2, p. 330-335 Article, book review (Other academic) Published National Category Philosophy Research subject Philosophy Identifiers urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-449120 (URN) images of paisleysWebb12 nov. 2024 · Stage theory and the personite problem. Alex Kaiserman. Published 12 November 2024. Philosophy. Analysis. Mark Johnston has recently argued that … images of pakistani cultural dresses